Georeactor Blog
RSS FeedAliens of Arxiv #2
After my first post on scientific pre-prints on alien life, Aliens of Arxiv, I was considering a follow-up - maybe focused on self-replicating / Von Neumann probes - but there were only a handful of authors in the space. Eventually I found more topics for completeness.
Background on Von Neumann probes and Fermi Paradox
An alien civilization determined to explore the universe might send out autonomous probes, which would land on planets and asteroids to harvest minerals and build more probes, and this exponential spread should search and/or mine the whole accessible universe.
If one alien civilization ever built their replicating probes, we should expect to see some (this was already discussed in 1980 paper Extraterrestrial Intelligent Beings do not Exist). This gets into the Fermi Paradox business of what makes reaching spacefaring civilization status so difficult, where I'm partial to prokaryote → eukaryote (since it is so weird!), followed by 'scary space radiation / extinction events' or maybe 'coming out of evolution with some empathy' being the Great Filter.
As for humans' work on probes - in the 1970s, Project Daedalus researched a proposal to build one interstellar craft in Jupiter's orbit. The mass of the ship would be about 1/2 of an aircraft carrier, 99% in fuel collected from the gas giant. This is the foundation for much space colonization research of the 70s-90s.
In 1980, Robert Freitas Jr. redesigned Daedalus as REPRO, a factory to land and manufacture new REPRO ships every 500 years. The ship was estimated to be 2x the mass and 100x the cost of Daedalus. To me this seems pessimistic. If your civilization could send out 10,000 one-use probes, you're covering way more ground than REPRO until you hit the exponential curve on a 7,000–10,000 year timeline.
Today Freitas works in nanotech manufacturing, so he probably has some thoughts on smaller probes. 🤔
Papers
A deep-learning search for technosignatures of 820 nearby stars
The goal of the Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence (SETI) is to quantify the prevalence of technological life…
Though this is a SETI / Breakthrough Initiatives project, the ML model in practice is helping them handle the problems of Earth-based interference and combining data from different telescopes.
Can China's FAST telescope detect extraterrestrial von-Neumann probes?
In the present paper we consider the Type-2.x and Type-3.x extraterrestrial von-Neumann probes and study the problem of…
A physics professor in Georgia (the country) has written multiple papers about Von Neumann probes. More recently he was second author on Black holes as tools for quantum computing by advanced extraterrestrial civilizations.
The model suggested here is a civilization with a Dyson Sphere around a star, which launches centimeter- or millimeter-size probes. Any larger, conventional probes need minerals which they'd only find on rocky planets and moons, which involves more taking off and landing, etc., so it would be better if you can create a nanobot which doesn't need so much.
If I understand this right, swarms of probes create some drag while traveling through space, which could affect luminosity in the star system or galaxy as a whole, but also the best technique would be to look for Dyson Spheres.
Discerning between different 'Oumuamua models by optical and infrared observations
The first interstellar object to be observed in our solar system 1I/2017 U1 'Oumuamua combines the lack of observable…
A plan to measure future interstellar objects with the new James-Webb telescope and figure out if 'Oumuamua type objects are solid or dust or nitrogen icebergs. Previously we read that if 'Oumuamua objects are plentiful then it's highly unlikely that they could all be nitrogen icebergs; if so a great deal of galactic mass is in similar objects.
Interstellar Objects from Broken Dyson Spheres
* Research Notes of the AAS , Volume 7 , Number 3 Citation Abraham Loeb 2023
This paper is more about the frequency that Dyson spheres would be bombarded with meteors and other junk. It's less bad if you had some kind of Dyson ring, but still it would need constant maintenance. After a civilization decays, the sphere will eventually break up and have pieces adrift in the cosmos. Loeb, a proponent of the lightsail theory, seems open to interstellar objects being pieces of spheres maybe:
Interestingly, the estimated size of `Oumuamua was about a hundred meters, potentially dictated by the bombardment rate of an old Dyson sphere.
This estimates of estimates of estimates thing is not worth including.
Near-Term Self-replicating Probes -- A Concept Design
Self-replicating probes are spacecraft with the capacity to create copies of themselves. Self-replication would…
Two researchers at the Initiative for Interstellar Studies modernize proposals for self-replicating probes. Looking from 2020 they are able to cite studies on modular and self-assembling robots, 3D printing in space, on-asteroid mining and manufacturing, and AI. The goal is to design a 100kg probe which can manufacture things from asteroids. The basis is a partial replicator model from NASA's Project RAMA. It would carry computer chips rather than try to manufacture a chip fab.
I'm not sure if we should consider these Von Neumann probes if they are bringing a set number of chips and then petering out. But of all the papers this was the most detailed and practical-sounding.
Project Lyra: Catching 1I/'Oumuamua Realistically with a Jupiter Encounter and Imminent Propulsion Options
Any missions to catch 1I/'Oumuamua have the daunting challenge of generating higher hyperbolic excess speeds than the…
I thought that this was (like a previous paper) discussing how to peek at future interstellar visitors, but Hibberd is proposing to launch a probe to slingshot around Jupiter and catch up to 'Oumuamua. Launch would be in 2030–2032 and intercept in the mid-2060s or 2070s (depending on resources and probe size).
The paper suggests astronomers are putting on the brakes until the opening of the Vera C. Rubin Observatory in Chile in late 2024, fearing that 'Oumuamua is nothing special. A 2021 article estimates that it will find five interceptable objects per year (though interstellar objects were supposed to be very rare and finding one, now multiple, was unexpected).
The Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence: A Realpolitik Consideration
In the vigorous academic debate over the risks of the Search for ExtraTerrestrial Intelligence (SETI) and active…
This 2020 article in "Space Policy" sparked an ongoing coversation (with the authors' latest reply published in 2023). Essentially the authors argue that a country which successfully detects or messages aliens will gain a huge advantage, and may use that to represent humanity as they see fit, and to control access to alien technology. Only a few countries have the initial resources to broadcast a message.
I don't have access to the original, but responses complain that the authors call for regulation of current SETI/METI, improving facility security, and even treating these programs on the same level as WMD research.
One author also had a 2021 paper Should We Lie to Extraterrestrials? which criticizes the content of the Voyager probes' Golden Records.
What are the demographics of stars visible to the naked eye?
Most of the brightest stars are nearby main sequence stars with spectral types B, A and F
Visible stars cluster around 100 parsecs (on a log scale) and many are red giants.
Why is there no von Neumann probe on Ceres? Error catastrophe can explain the Fermi-Hart Paradox
It has been argued that self-replicating robotic probes could spread to all stars of our galaxy within a timespan that…
I am full of questions about why this paper came out of Newcastle University's Institute for Ageing, but OK.
Ceres is mentioned in the title because the asteroid belt is seen as a prime target for Von Neumann probes, and for an astronomical mystery which I didn't know about: Bright spots on Ceres.
The cited theories for this include some wild scientific papers from the 70s: The zoo hypothesis.
Assuming that the probe replication introduces errors over time, the author estimates production falls off in a 225 light year radius around the origin (for context, the Milky Way is 100,000 light years across and 1,000 light years thick, so ~1/200,000th of our galaxy). This is an interesting problem but I would hope if someone sends out Von Neumann probes, they can also make radio beacons with instructions? The internet tells me that we're visible above background radiation for longer:
military radar transmissions set up during the Cold War to detect incoming ballistic missiles have the power and frequency characteristics to be detected over hundreds of light-years
The author's final conclusions are that the exponential payoff of Von Neumann probe design takes much too long for finite-living aliens and their institutions (similar to what I was thinking earlier with REPRO). So rational actors are doing conventional science or have a bubble of Von Neumann probes around them, but apparently not including us.
